Pillario Property Management

Pillario Property Management

3.7(302 Google reviews)
HOAProperty management company

Profile updated November 9, 2026

#22of 71 management firms we track in Indianapolis · how we rank
3.7 ▲Google rating · market avg 3.6
302Google reviews · more than 86% of Indianapolis firms
HOAproperty types we list them for
6professionals we track at this firm

About Pillario Property Management

Pillario Property Management manages single-family homes and investment properties in the Central Indiana area, including Fishers. They focus on property owners seeking responsive and professional management services.

Services

tenant placementrent collectionproperty maintenance coordinationon-site managementonline owner portal with property income and expense trackingsecure online rent payment portalresident communication services24/7 responsivenessinvestment property managementproperty upkeep oversight
Address9940 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038
OnlineInstagram
Office hours
monday8 AM–12 PM, 1–5 PM
tuesday8 AM–12 PM, 1–5 PM
wednesday8 AM–12 PM, 1–5 PM
thursday8 AM–12 PM, 1–5 PM
friday8 AM–12 PM, 1–5 PM
saturdayClosed
sundayClosed

Looking for a new management company?

Tell us about your building once and request proposals from the firms you pick. Free for boards.

Request Proposals

Location and nearby firms

How Pillario Property Management compares in Indianapolis

Pillario Property ManagementCRM PropertiesPMI IndianapolisWILMOTH Group - Indianapolis Property Management
Google rating3.7 stars4.9 stars4.5 stars4.3 stars
Google reviews302525663850
Property typesHOAHOAHOAHOA
WebsiteYesYesYesYes

Team (6 professionals tracked)

Megan Schmieman

Asset Manager

Megan Combs

Multifamily Asset Manager

Amanda Booher

Property Manager

Megan S

Asset Manager

Harly Materan

Leasing Professional

Harly M

Leasing Professional

Frequently asked questions

What does Pillario Property Management manage?

Pillario Property Management lists these services on its website: tenant placement, rent collection, property maintenance coordination, on-site management, online owner portal with property income and expense tracking, secure online rent payment portal, resident communication services, 24/7 responsiveness, investment property management, property upkeep oversight.

How is Pillario Property Management rated?

Pillario Property Management holds a 3.7 star Google rating across 302 reviews, compared with a 3.6 star average among the 71 management firms we track in Indianapolis. Google reviews often come from residents as well as board members.

Where is Pillario Property Management located?

Pillario Property Management is at 9940 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038. Phone: (317) 643-2585.

Is this your firm?

Claim your PropertyManagementSearch listing to correct your details, add the property types you manage, and hear from boards in Indianapolis looking for a new manager. Free.

Other management firms in Indianapolis

CRM Properties

CRM Properties

4.9(525 Google reviews)
HOA600 E Carmel Dr Suite #126, Carmel, IN 46032 · (317) 537-0005
PMI Indianapolis

PMI Indianapolis

4.5(663 Google reviews)
HOA13110 Harrell Pkwy Ste 100 Office 207, Noblesville, IN 46060 · (317) 572-7036
WILMOTH Group - Indianapolis Property Management

WILMOTH Group - Indianapolis Property Management

4.3(850 Google reviews)
HOA9855 Crosspoint Blvd #148, Indianapolis, IN 46256 · (317) 842-3400
Red Door Property Management

Red Door Property Management

4.5(475 Google reviews)
HOA3815 River Crossing Pkwy #100, Indianapolis, IN 46240 · (317) 660-1626
Kirkpatrick Management Company

Kirkpatrick Management Company

4.1(901 Google reviews)
HOACondo5702 Kirkpatrick Way, Indianapolis, IN 46220 · (317) 570-4358

Renu Property Management

3.7(1,277 Google reviews)
HOA2325 Pointe Pkwy #250, Carmel, IN 46032 · (800) 252-2820
Pillario Property Management: Indianapolis, IN Property Management | License, Ratings & Contact | PropertyManagementSearch